My father and I have owned a pawn shop for many years and I am very familiar - actually, an EXPERT in gold and silver testing. I did it for him (up to less than a year ago) for about 20+ years.
*****About 95-98% of all people who claim "testing" for gold or silver, whether knowingly or unknowingly, are testing incorrectly.*****
A chemical test for gold OR silver only tests for the "presence" of a specific metal.... It does NOT test for plating, the most important consideration. If an item is silver plated with sterling silver as the plating, it will test positive as sterling silver.
Simply put, saying that an item tests positive for silver or gold is not the same as saying "solid". It means that where the chemical was applied, the "metal" for the test was present, and it turned positive.
For another example: You can also test an object to see if it there is a "presence" of 18k, and it WILL test positive if it is [18k] plated. Again, it is because [it] reacts with the 18k in the plating.
Testing acids are not "intelligent". They don't "know" they need to ignore the metal plating and "look" below the surface and test the metal below the surface metal. The solution only reacts to the existence of a substance, and if it is present (i.e. in the plating), even along with other metals such as brass, nickel, or aluminum below the plating, it will test positive and then you have a seller saying, "Not marked but tested positive for Sterling Silver", or "Not marked, but tested positive for 18k". Well... Duh...
The ONLY way, I REPEAT, the only way to genuinely test an object [not marked] is to take a file, remover a top layer of metal in any area of the item to remove any plating material, and carefully apply the acid to this area (without it touching the other unscratched area) and note the reaction. This is true of either the chemical tests or the electronic tests. The rule of thumb for all professionals in the jewelry and pawn business is: If it isn't marked .925, .900, SS, S.Silver, sterling,18k, 14k, etc, it is not.
Granted, it is possible for anyone to get a small metal stamp and stamp something on a piece that is not gold or silver (Oddly, this is extremely rare. I have only seen this once in 20 years of a pawn business!), but it is even rarer that an artist would make a piece and not stamp it.
This is especially true for Great Britain (they have VERY strict laws regarding the jewelry marking and hallmarks).
Believe it or not, Mexico is very good about marking their jewelry. Mexican and British jewelry are the finest in the world because of the strict and stringent marking guidelines by their governments. So, if it is being advertised as American, Britain or Mexican and the seller says "unmarked"... it is unmarked for a reason. It's because it isn't solid.
Even the most basic, small, and rustic jewelry companies and jewelers (in ANY country) know to mark their jewelry. They know until they do, the item is in question until it is properly marked!
If the "tested item" you just bought was tested, and it does NOT have a very noticeable scratched blemish somewhere (about the size of dime or as large as a quarter), it was not tested properly- or tested at all.
I have also seen, and I will try to type this without laughing, lots of ALPACA "sterling" advertised. One seller just last week in the description listed the buckle as "Displays a stamp saying ALPACA but we are sure it is solid sterling even though not marked".
ALPACA is another term for nickel silver. It contains NO silver content AT ALL. Zero. Nada. None. Nothing. Period. Don't believe me? Google "ALPACA silver" or look [it] up on www.wikipedia.com
and see what definition you get. I'll save you the time, it's plain
old nickel mixed with copper, aluminum, iron or sometimes just cheap
pot-metal and then maybe plated with sterling, IF you're lucky.
Ask your potential seller HOW was the test done. You will be surprised by the answers you receive! By the way, turning green in pickle-juice is NOT a valid test for solid sterling silver - believe it or not!
For some more GREAT information on sterling silver, search for a sellers guide written by eBay user sparklebizsilverjewelry. Great info in their guide too!
PLEASE INDICATE BELOW if this was helpful so that it will remain visible to help other bidders! Thanks!!
Guide created: 10/20/07 (updated 07/03/08)


Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our